Category: shelter

The importance of Group Shelters Fjallraven Windsack 3

What safety equipment do you guys carry with you when you’re out in the nature? Whistle, orange survival bag, foil blanket, head torch, first aid…….check!  How many of you carry a group shelter or “bothy bag”?  Running courses in the Highlands of Scotland, we would put a conservative number of our clients turning up with one at 50%.

“But I always carry an orange survival bag with me, this does the same thing right?” Yes and No, we’ll come back to that argument in a second!

 

Cast your minds back to School (daunting I know), now remind yourself of the 4 main ways the body loses heat…..here’s a quick reminder;

Radiation – We are constantly radiating body heat to the external environment, the 2nd rule of thermodynamics states that “heat passes from a warm source to cold, to try and reach an equilibrium”.  This is why we wear clothes right?  The clothing basically stops the heat dissipating from our body quickly, and traps warm air against our skin.

Conduction – Same as above, if you lie, lean or make contact with a colder surface than your body temperature, you will lose heat to that cold source. Hence why we use sleeping mats/thermorests.

Evaporation – As we all know sweating is natures way of losing heat as quickly as possible when we are trying to achieve “Homeostasis”, the act of balancing our body temperature with the outside climate. This is paramount in hot climates or when exercising.  However evaporation can be one of your biggest enemies when you are soaked with rain or sweat and are stationary. Your body warms the water particles against your skin, turning the water into vapour, and carrying heat and energy at quicker rate than air away from you.

Convection – In an outdoor setting convection is “wind chill”.We’ve all been there, hanging out your hoop, overheating going up a steep hill, then you get to the top you rest for 5 minutes all the while getting hit by the wind, you wish you were on the move again! The wind moves heat away from the body at a faster rate. (This shows the importance of the layering systems in clothing) Below is a wind/temp conversion chart.

This goes to show you that it can be 10 degrees, but with a 30mph wind, it’ll feel like -1!

The Gruesome Twosome

In the majority of hypothermia cases in the outdoors it’s very rarely just the one heat loss mechanisms that does the harm, usually a mix of two or more.  The real problem is when individuals get wet, either through sweat or rain/snow (Evaporation) and there is a significant wind chill (Convection).  Evaporation+Convection = Big trouble! This is when the “rule of three’s” comes into force, without adequate protection from the elements you’re going to last a maximum of 3 hours before the symptoms of Hypothermia are so bad…..it’s probably too late.

Lunchtime in the FR Windsack 3

Group Shelters and the Fjallraven Windsack 3

Like most things in life it’s the simple things that can make all the difference.  The fjallraven Windsack 3 and other Group shelters are basically a tent material that can fit individuals, or a number of you in and keep you sheltered from the elements.  Group shelters aren’t just a survival piece of kit, but can also be used to have your lunch in, if you can’t get out of the wind.

So looking back at the 4 mechanisms of heat loss the Wind sack 3 and group shelters will stop;

Radiation – Fjallraven use the same materials as the outer on their tents (40D TripleRip nylon) , this means that any radiated heat is trapped in the bag itself and is allowed to freely circulate.  This is even more evident when there are two or more of you in there, the temperature will noticeably rise quickly

Conduction – When using a group shelter, ruck sacks should be placed on the ground and sat-on to stop conduction to the ground.

Evaporation – Ok, so a group shelter won’t stop the act of evaporation, however the heated vapour will be trapped in the bag itself to avoid excess heat loss. The great thing about the wind sack 3 is the three individual zippers, which allow airing and stop excess condensation on the inside.

Convection – You’re still going to feel the wind if it’s strong enough in a group shelter, but it’s not going to be able to draw the heat away from you at the same rate.

A miserable way to spend a night, but will save your life.

As was stated above “an orange survival bag does the same thing”, yes it does, but can only really be used once and is a “one person shelter”.  Don’t ditch the orange survival bag, just make sure you carry a group shelter with you from now on.

It’s worth noting that the orange survival bag should be pulled over the head, with an “air hole” made for breathing/avoiding condensation (pictured).  This will assure radiated heat is trapped in the bag with you.

 

 

 

Most group shelters will come in bright colours, this is obviously so rescuers can spot you, should you need to deploy it “in anger”, the Wind Sack 3 comes in UN blue. The two colours that are unnatural and are picked up easiest by the human eye are Orange and UN blue, so when buying a group shelter bear this in mind.

Two other great features of the Wind sack 3 that we’ve noticed are the reflective tape around the outside….easily picked up at night, but also the carabineer on cordage (pictured) that you can attach to you in high winds (those of you who use a group shelter regularly will know all about the potential for the wind to rip it straight out your hands!)

Let’s be honest here, many of you will be on a budget and might not be able to afford the Wind sack 3 , however a trip to any reasonably reputable outdoor shop and you’ll be faced with a wide range and at a reasonably cheap price.

Don’t just take our word for it, here’s an incident that happened this winter in the Cairngorms

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Establishing Shelter in multi-environment settings

 

Snow-Holeing

Be it necessity or leisure, the snow hole is in many cases the most effective form of shelter within a winter mountain environment. Yet unlike woodland shelter, there has to be a lot more judgment and understanding of the building medium and topographical features to avoid an unpleasant or in some cases be a potentially fatal experience. The snow hole has been an essential means of survival for many over the years – from indigenous communities; the famous Heroes of Telemark; to present-day mountaineers.

 

For myself and many others, Bushcraft is having the skills, confidence and experience to travel through and live in a wilderness setting for a prolonged length of time. The “human animal” has the ability to survive in practically any environment on the face of the planet. This greatly depends upon the careful planning of appropriate equipment – much of which has been evolved and refined over time. However, it is experience and skill, combined with this equipment, that best equip the individual to withstand the harshest of conditions.

Let’s put the need for effective shelter into context. Many have heard of the “rule of threes” a hierarchy of the essentials and time scales needed to sustain human life;

• 3 minutes without oxygen
• 3 hours without shelter
• 3 days without water
• 3 weeks without food

These rules are, of course, all circumstantial and need to be considered alongside a number of other factors. In a hostile habitat such as the Cairngorm Plateau, in the depths of winter, three hours can be an over estimate. Hypothermia can set in at an alarming rate. Technical hypothermia is the loss of a mere 2°C from your body’s core temperature. Contributing factors such as wind chill and heat loss through perspiration evaporation, will speed the process up, as water conducts heat away from the body five times faster than air. When you factor wind chill into the equation, heat loss occurs twenty-five times faster than on a still day. The need for shelter is paramount!

Location, Location, Location

The first thing to think about is where to start excavating your snow hole. Prevailing winds are typically south-west in this country, causing wind-carried snow to lay deepest in the north-east lee (or sheltered) slopes. Snow depth of course depends on the recent wind conditions, and close attention to weather patterns should be made prior to any expedition. In Scotland, the snow can lie for up to 10 metres deep, which is ideal for excavating a snow hole. I have heard many horror stories about groups and individuals staying out for the night and digging into the snow pack, only to find that the snow depth is not sufficient to house everyone.

Think you won’t get avalanched in Britain? Think again! Being avalanched whilst digging, or worse being buried whilst inside a snow hole is a real possibility. It should be noted that an avalanche can occur on a slope with an angle as little as 20°! The Scottish Avalanche Information Service or SAIS is the one-stop-shop for mountain snow conditions and should be adhered to prior to heading out.
An avalanche probe should be utilised to test for any discrepancies within the snow pack, feeling for any excessively hard snow with wind slab (hard packed freshly-blown snow) lying on top. An avalanche pit is also a useful tool to get an idea of the local stability within the different layers in the snow. A hidden layer of Graupel (when snow is rotated in storm conditions to form ‘ball bearings’) under wind slab can act as lubrication for any subsequent snow layers, increasing the risk of avalanche.

Choice of Snow Hole

Temperature will dictate which style of snow hole is more relevant. In Scandinavia and the Arctic regions, a ‘Kaloo’ or traditional Norwegian set up is the preferred choice. The idea is to dig a corridor straight into the snow pack and leave raised sleeping platforms either side. This has two distinct advantages: The first being that it keeps you closer to the top of the cave, where the warm air from body and stove rises. The second is, as the cold air drops to the floor, it is allowed to escape through the doorway, which is in line with or often lower than the sleeping platforms – in effect acting as a cold sink. The roof has to be perfectly smooth and rounded to support the weight of the snow being exerted from above and the sides. In warmer climates, however, the Kaloo is prone to collapse.

In the British mountains, where the ambient temperature rarely drops below -10° and is more than often in the -1° to -7° range, it is more important to try and hold onto some of this cold air to stop the inner surface melting and dripping onto you. In this case, a snow cave may be more appropriate. This can be dug quickly by two or more people. Set at a planned distance apart, two doorways are dug in unison and joined once inside. The sleeping spaces are on the floor which encourages the retention of the cold air and expulsion of any warm air quickly. Once either type of snow hole has been dug, the doors can be capped from the top downwards by cutting blocks from above the chosen site and sliding them into place.

Carbon Monoxide

Believe it or not more people succumb to Carbon Monoxide poisoning than by the collapse of their snow hole. Carbon Monoxide is produced from using a gas or petrol stove in an enclosed space and is formed when there is not enough Oxygen to produce Carbon Dioxide. Two essentials are needed to counter this. The first is a small hole punched through the roof with a ski or walking pole to allow the Carbon Monoxide to escape (CO is slightly lighter than air). The pole is left in place to clear any spindrift that may accumulate during the night. The second is a candle, (apart from the obvious extinguishment of the flame telling you that there’s not enough oxygen for the flame to burn) which should be slightly flickering to confirm there is a small amount of air circulation throughout the sleeping space.

Equipment

As we all know the mountainous regions of the world are amongst the harshest and unforgiving environments on the planet. The old adage of “there’s no such thing as bad weather, just bad equipment” holds true! Apart from having the usual ice-axe, crampons, water proofs, map, compass, weather reports and spare clothing, you should be equipped with an avalanche probe, snow shovel, bone saw, a good 4-season sleeping bag and bivvie bag, a reliable stove and most important of all…. good quality training.

Kit

Whilst staying out overnight the correct sleeping system has to be used depending on the weather, type of shelter being used and clients experience and expectations.

A full weather forecast including Synoptics is carried out in advance of a course running . When taking clients that I have not worked with before or with no background in Survival skills I will usually insist that they use a bivvy bag and 4 season sleeping bag. Where possible a synthetic sleeping bag is preferred to a down bag. Apart from the well known fact that down when wet loses it insulation, I have found that clients do not look after down bags in the way they should and, as a result, the bags have lost all of their loft. I know from trips to the Alps, Norway and Siberia that you should never use a down bag for any longer than two weeks at a time as the down gets compressed, damp and losses its heat retention.

Bivvie bags are of paramount importance. The Bivvie bag provides a water proof barrier between the outside environment and the sleeping bag. The bag itself should be made of a breathable material such as Gortex or Event to avoid a build up of moisture on the inside surface. It is common for ill informed clients to turn up with a plastic survival bag, this of course doesn’t allow the free flow of moisture to the outside surface and the result is a damp sleeping bag and in turn a wet and uncomfortable experience.

There is no margin for error when selecting a sleeping system when Snow holing or in an arctic environment. The majority of heat will be sucked out through the ground, the first law of Thermodynamics states- “heat dissipates from warmth towards cold”. This is to say that any warmth that you create is always trying to escape towards a cold source. The largest surface area for this warmth to escape is whilst you are lying down on an extremely cold surface. Modern day advancements have come up with the thermorest where by you fill an inflatable mattress with a poor heat conductor – air. A roll map that traps air within its body is also valuable. When in an emergency situation vegetation such as Polytrichium (star moss) bracken/ferns and spruce and Fir can be used. A highly effective technique is to cut a large amount of Spruce to the length of your fingers to your elbow, sharpen the stem and insert into the ground in an upright position. Continue this in rows and columns until you have a space large enough to lie down on. As you lie on the upright spruce they are bent down and come to rest on their neighbour thus creating a mattress with air trapped underneath leaving you off the ground.

It is impossible to tell how someone’s body and mental state will react to sleeping out in adverse weather conditions ie. Getting wet during the night or waking up in the woodlands in minus zero degree temperature, hypothermia and other cold injuries are a real risk. For the sake of health and safety they must bring everything on the kit list, this will include spare warm clothing. If the weather permits it we can always thin gear out before the course starts.

One of the most common mistakes I have seen is to wear a cotton base-layer. Cotton and man-made fibres on the whole tend to absorb the water and not release it leaving the wearer sodden, and as discussed previously water is exceptionally good at conducting transferring warmth away from the body at an 80% greater rate than the likes of wool. We as humans have been creating and manipulating fibres for the past 20,000 years, nature has been at it for over 40,000,000 years! The best advice to give to beginners is to use a man-made wicking fibre (usually Full of holes to help with heat retention) and a number of wool layers (which in itself is a natural wicker) depending on thWool when wet holds some 70% of heat that the user emits and thus is a supreme insulator.

Bushcraft and Wilderness Survival Courses in Scotland

During the final Jacobean uprising, culminating in the battle of Culloden in 1976 the Government troops were guided through Moray-shire and Inverness-shire by clans loyal to the Hanoverian royal family. In John Prebbles book “Culloden” he states that the English soldiers were amazed when the Highlanders in freezing weather dipped their kilts and plaids in to a stream and continued to wrap themselves up in it to sleep. This isn’t as crazy as it seems. By wrapping themselves up in wet wool meant that they lost very little insulation and when the material froze it acted as a wind proof shield.

Similarly Mallory, who perished on his attempt on Mount Everest, adorned tweed climbing ‘outers’. Of course tweed is made from wool which is insulative but modern day studies have revealed that the tweed stored heat when the wearer was warm and as the wearer cooled down released heat back to him!